Why AI Might Be Citing Your Outdated Content

The Clustering Problem

Here's something that will ruin your day if you've been creating lots of "keyword-targeted" pages: AI search doesn't rank them. It clusters them.

Traditional SEO told you to create separate pages for "best running shoes," "top running shoes," and "running shoe reviews." Three pages, three keyword targets. Google would rank each one. You'd capture more traffic.

AI doesn't work that way. It looks at those three pages and thinks: "These are basically the same thing." It groups them into a cluster. Then it picks one page to represent the entire cluster. The other two become invisible.

Worse: the page it picks might be an old one. Your freshly updated content with current information? Clustered away. Your outdated page from 2023? That's the one AI is citing.

What Bing Actually Said

In December 2025, Bing's Webmaster Blog published something remarkable: actual documentation of how AI search handles duplicate content. Not vague guidance—specific mechanisms.

Read that again. "Potentially an outdated version." Your 2023 blog post might be the one AI is citing, while your comprehensive 2025 update sits invisible in the same cluster.

But it gets worse:

You thought you were targeting multiple intents with multiple pages. AI thinks you're just repeating yourself. It can't tell which page matches which intent—so it guesses. And when it guesses wrong, your perfectly-targeted content gets matched to the wrong queries.

Here's the kicker: every duplicate page you create makes the problem worse. Crawlers have limited budgets. If they're wasting time on your 47 keyword variations, they're not finding your actual updates. Your fresh content takes longer to appear in AI results—because your old content is hogging the crawler's attention.

How to Tell AI Which Version Is Current

If AI is picking the wrong page from your cluster, it's probably because you're not giving it clear signals about which version is current. Here's what actually matters:

Lastmod Timestamps

This is boring but important. The lastmod field in your sitemap tells crawlers when your content actually changed.

Most sites get this wrong. They set lastmod to when the sitemap was generated, not when the content changed. AI sees every page as "updated today" and has no idea which content is actually fresh.

Do this: Set lastmod to the actual date your content changed. Use ISO 8601 format. Be honest—if you just fixed a typo, don't pretend you rewrote the article.

IndexNow: The Instant Update Button

Sitemaps are passive. Crawlers check them when they feel like it. IndexNow is active—you ping search engines the moment your content changes.

For time-sensitive content, this matters. You publish a correction, ping IndexNow, and AI knows within minutes that your content changed. Without it, you're waiting for the next crawl—which could be days.

Why Your Competitor Gets Cited Instead

Here's a scenario that happens constantly: you have better content than your competitor. You update it more often. You know more about the topic. But AI cites them instead of you.

Why? Because they have one great page. You have five pretty-good pages. Their signals are concentrated. Yours are fragmented.

Your competitor's one page has 100 backlinks. Your five pages have 20 each. Mathematically, you have more authority. But AI sees five weak pages vs one strong page. It cites the strong page.

What to Do About It

The Consolidation Playbook

Stop creating content variations. Start consolidating.

"But I need different pages for different audiences!" Maybe. But only if the content is actually different. If you're just changing a headline and swapping some images, AI will cluster it. Save yourself the trouble and consolidate proactively.

AI Doesn't Search Like You Think

One more thing that changes everything: AI doesn't match your page to a single query. It runs multiple queries and synthesizes the results.

Someone asks "what's the best CRM for small businesses?" Traditional search shows 10 blue links. AI search does something different: it runs sub-queries for "CRM pricing comparison," "CRM ease of use," "CRM integrations," synthesizes all the results, and gives you one answer.

This means you're not competing for a keyword anymore. You're competing to be cited in a synthesis. And synthesis favors sources that are comprehensive, authoritative, and don't waste the AI's time with near-duplicate content it has to cluster away.

How This All Fits Together

Based on everything Bing and Google have published, here's what we think happens when AI picks a citation:

1. Query breakdown: AI splits your question into sub-queries
2. Retrieval: It fetches candidate sources for each sub-query
3. Clustering: Similar pages get grouped together
4. Selection: AI picks ONE page per cluster to represent it
5. Authority check: It weighs E-E-A-T signals on the selected pages
6. Freshness check: It considers lastmod and update signals
7. Synthesis: It generates a response using the winners
8. Citation: It attributes claims to the pages that earned it

You can influence steps 3-6. Consolidate your content (step 3-4). Build authority on fewer pages (step 5). Keep your timestamps honest (step 6). The rest is out of your hands.

The Short Version

AI clusters your duplicate content and picks one page to cite. Make sure it picks the right one: consolidate aggressively, keep timestamps accurate, and stop creating keyword variations. One great page beats five okay pages every time.

Written by

Patrick Gallagher

Founder, Fokal

Patrick researches how AI systems discover, evaluate, and cite brands. He founded Fokal to help brands understand and optimize their visibility in AI search.

LinkedIn X